The race between the Tar Heels and the Zags for No. 1 in the CBS Sports early Top 25 And 1 is getting tight
North Carolina’s already really good roster got a boost Saturday when Pete Nance announced a commitment to the Tar Heels. He’s a super-senior graduate transfer from Northwestern who should more or less play the role of a stretch-4 that Brady Manek filled last season alongside Armando Bacot.
Manek exhausted his eligibility.
He’s the only UNC starter not returning.
Nance averaged 14.6 points and 6.5 rebounds last season while shooting 45.2% from 3-point range on 3.1 attempts per game. So he didn’t shoot as often from the perimeter at Northwestern as Manek did at North Carolina or, before that, Oklahoma. But the 6-foot-10 All-Big Ten performer made enough 3-pointers at an incredible rate to suggest he can be a reliable floor-spacer in Hubert Davis’ program.
Does Nance make UNC better?
But, after considering everything I know to consider, I’ve decided to leave the Tar Heels at No. 2 in the 2022-23 CBS Sports Preseason Top 25 And 1 — one spot behind top-ranked Gonzaga. Put simply, I just like Gonzaga’s roster a little better than I like North Carolina’s roster. The rosters are close in my mind. Very close. But I’m giving a slight edge to the Zags thanks to the fact that they’re returning six of the top eight scorers from a team that was the No. 1 overall seed in the 2022 NCAA Tournament — among them two-time All-American Drew Timme and double-digit scorers Julian Strawther and Rasir Bolton. Gonzaga has also been bolstered this offseason by the arrival of transfers Malachi Smith and Efton Reid. Smith averaged 19.9 points, 6.7 rebounds and 3.0 assists last season at Chattanooga and is the reigning Southern Conference Player of the Year. Reid is a former five-star recruit who played last season at LSU.
Top 25 And 1 rankings
|The Bulldogs’ ranking is based on Gonzaga returning six of the top eight scorers from a team that finished first at KenPom – among them Drew Timme and Julian Strawther. That provides Mark Few with a strong veteran core that will be supported by transfers – most notably Malachi Smith, a combo guard who averaged 19.9 points for Chattanooga last season while earning Southern Conference Player of the Year honors.||—||28-4|
|The Tar Heels’ ranking is based on North Carolina returning every rotation player except Brady Manek from a team that played for the national title – among them All-American Armando Bacot, NCAA Tournament star Caleb Love and defensive specialist Leaky Black. The addition of Northwestern transfer Pete Nance solidifies UNC as the ACC favorite.||—||29-10|
|The Cougars’ ranking is based on Houston returning a core featuring both players it lost to injury in December (Marcus Sasser and Tramon Mark) plus Jamal Shead. That’s three double-digit scorers Kelvin Sampson should have to pair with Jarace Walker, a 5-star freshman who is among the reasons Houston will once again be the favorite in the AAC.||—||32-6|
|The Wildcats’ ranking is based on CBS Sports National Player of the Year Oscar Tshiebwe returning (alongside fellow starter Sahvir Wheeler) and being joined by a recruiting class highlighted by five-star guard Cason Wallace. Keion Brooks entering the transfer portal wasn’t ideal but will simply create a bigger opportunity for Jacob Toppin, who had better shooting percentages than Brooks from the field and 3-point line last season.||—||26-8|
|The Blue Devils’ ranking is based on Duke returning Jeremy Roach and pairing him with the nation’s top-ranked recruiting class that includes three of the best four prospects in the Class of 2022 – plus Illinois transfer Jacob Grandison and Northwestern transfer Ryan Young. Jon Scheyer’s first team will be light on experience but loaded with NBA prospects.||—||32-7|
|The Razorbacks’ ranking is based on Arkansas losing every meaningful piece besides Davonte Davis, which isn’t ideal. But Eric Musselman’s team should still be a Final Four contender thanks to the addition of three five-star freshman (Nick Smith, Anthony Black and Jordan Walsh) plus impactful transfers like Ricky Council (Wichita State), Jalen Graham (Arizona State), Makhel Mitchell (Rhode Island) and Makhi Mitchell (Rhode Island).||—||28-9|
|The Bears’ ranking is based on LJ Cryer, Adam Flagler and Flo Thamba returning from a team that shared the Big 12 title with Kansas. The addition of 5-star guard Keyonte George should give Baylor one of the sport’s best backcourts.||—||27-7|
|The Jayhawks’ ranking is based on Kansas returning a core of Jalen Wilson, Dajuan Harris and Joseph Yusefu from the team that won the national championship. A top-five recruiting class highlighted by 5-star prospects Gradey Dick, MJ Rice and Ernest Udeh – plus Texas Tech transfer Kevin McCullar – should have Bill Self’s program competing for yet another Big 12 title.||—||34-6|
|The Volunteers’ ranking is based on Tennessee returning four of its top five scorers – among them Santiago Vescovi and Josiah-Jordan James. Tennessee will miss one-and-done point guard Kennedy Chandler but should still be a factor near the top of the SEC thanks in part to the addition of five-star forward Julian Phillips.||—||27-8|
|The Bruins’ ranking is based on Jaime Jaquez, Jules and Tyger Campbell providing Mick Cronin with a veteran core to pair with a top-10 recruiting class highlighted by five-star prospects Amari Bailey and Adem Bona. If the freshman are strong from the start, UCLA should have a chance to make the Final Four for the second time in three years.||—||27-8|
|The Bluejays’ ranking is based on Creighton returning five of the top seven scorers from a team that advanced to the Round of 32 of the NCAA Tournament. The addition of South Dakota State transfer Baylor Scheierman, the reigning Summit League Player of the Year, makes Greg McDermott’s team the clear favorite in the Big East.||—||23-12|
|The Longhorns’ ranking is based on Texas returning the top two scorers from a team that finished 15th at KenPom – namely Timmy Allen and Marcus Carr, each of whom is using a fifth year of eligibility. Chris Beard is adding to that core a top-15 recruiting class highlighted by two five-star prospects (Dillon Mitchell and Arterio Morris) and Iowa State transfer Tyrese Hunter.||—||22-12|
|The Tigers’ ranking is based on Auburn returning four of the top six scorers – among them K.D. Johnson, Wendell Green and Allen Flanigan – from a team that earned a No. 2 seed in the NCAA Tournament. That core will be joined by a nice incoming class highlighted by Morehead State transfer Johni Broome and five-star center Yohan Traore.||—||28-6|
|The Horned Frogs’ ranking is based on TCU returning the top six scorers from a team that beat Kansas late and finished 26th at KenPom. That experienced core should have Jamie Dixon’s team competing for what could be TCU’s first Big 12 title.||—||21-13|
|The Wildcats’ ranking is based on Villanova returning six of the top nine scorers from its Final Four team – among them Brandon Slater and Caleb Daniels. Jay Wright left Kyle Neptune with a nice core that should allow the new Villanova coach to keep the Wildcats in the national conversation.||—||30-8|
|The Hoosiers’ ranking is based on Indiana returning the top three scorers from a team that made the NCAA Tournament – among them Trayce Jackson-Davis, who could be a candidate for Big Ten Player of the Year. Indiana’s recruiting class is ranked fifth nationally and highlighted by 5-star prospects Jalen Hood-Schifino and Malik Reneau.||—||21-14|
|The Aggies’ ranking is based on Texas A&M returning every relevant player — besides Quenton Jackson — who helped the Aggies make the championship game of the NIT. Buzz Williams made the NCAA Tournament in Year 4 at both Marquette and Virginia Tech and should do the same at Texas A&M.||—||27-13|
|The Wildcats’ ranking is based on Arizona returning a core of Azuolas Tubelis, Kerr Kriisa, Pelle Larsson and Oumar Ballo. That, combined with the additions of transfers Courtney Ramey (Texas) and Cedric Henderson Jr. (Campbell), should be enough to keep Tommy Lloyd’s program near the top of the Pac-12 standings.||—||33-4|
|The Wolverines’ ranking is based on a returning core of Hunter Dickinson and Terrance Williams being joined by an incoming class highlighted by Princeton transfer Jaelin Llewellyn and top-40 prospect Jett Howard, the latter of whom was named MVP at the Iverson Classic. Juwan Howad should have the Wolverines in the NCAA Tournament for the third straight season.||—||19-15|
|The Ducks’ ranking is based on Oregon returning three of its top six scorers — among them double-digit scorers Will Richardson and Quincy Guerrier. A recruiting class featuring 5-star prospect Kel’el Ware, JUCO All-American Tyrone Williams and Colorado transfer Keeshawn Barthelemy should allow Dana Altman to have a nice bounce-back season.||—||20-15|
|The Crimson Tide’s ranking is based on Alabama returning four of its top eight scorers from an NCAA Tournament team – among them Noah Gurley and Charles Bediako. Nate Oats should combine that core with a top-five recruiting class featuring two 5-star prospects and Ohio transfer Mark Sears.||—||19-14|
|The Boilermakers’ ranking is based on Purdue returning three of the top seven scorers from a team that made the Sweet 16 of the NCAA Tournament – among them All-American candidate Zach Edey. Admittedly, that’s not a lot — but Matt Painter deserves the benefit of the doubt based on the consistency with which he runs his program.||—||29-8|
|The Flyers’ ranking is based on Dayton returning the top five scorers from a team that just missed the NCAA Tournament – among them double-digit scorers Daron Holmes and Toumani Camara. If Anthony Grant can keep his talented freshmen out of the transfer portal, the Flyers’ future is bright in the Atlantic 10.||—||24-11|
|The Buckeyes’ ranking is based on Zed Key and Justice Sueing returning and being joined by a top-five recruiting class featuring four top-65 prospects. Transfers Sean McNeil (West Virginia), Isaac Likekele (Oklahoma State) and Tanner Holden (Wright State) will provide Chris Holtmann with a nice trio of veteran newcomers.||—||20-12|
|The Spartans’ ranking is based on Michigan State returning five of the top nine scorers from a team that advanced to the Round of 32 of the NCAA Tournament. Max Christie’s decision to remain in the NBA Draft is a blow – but Tom Izzo should still coach in his 25th straight NCAA Tournament next March.||—||23-13|
|The Billikens’ ranking is based on Saint Louis returning four starters – among them backcourt mates Yuri Collins and Gibson Jimerson – and adding transfer Javon Pickett, who averaged 11.1 points at Missouri last season. SLU is also getting back Javonte Perkins, who led the team in scoring two seasons ago before missing last season with a torn ACL.||—||23-12|